Thursday, November 16, 2006

Sacha Cohen has been promoting his new movie by giving in-character interviews in his Borat persona. Some of these have been very funny. (Empire magazine: "Which is your favorite James Bond Movie?" Borat: "It hard to say. I am like all five.")

It would have been very easy to mistake the Daily Mail's "Borat's Guide to Britain" as a contribution to this genre. In fact it is a parody. "Here, David Thomas imagine what guidelines he might have for immigrants visiting Britain" (I particularly like the combination of 'immigrants' and 'visiting')

A parody of Borat is a rather pointless exercise: I recall that impressionist Mike Yarwood declined to "do" Frank Spencer or Edna Everage, because they were fictitious characters who were already being "done" by Michael Crawford and Barry Humphries. But you might expect the parodist to get the joke. Borat has a set of prejudices which no sensible person could possibly share; and he doesn't understand America at all. The character in the Daily Mail piece has a set of prejudices shared by the editorial staff of the Daily Mail; and understands the U.K very well indeed.

The piece could be taken as a lexicon of Daily Mail prejudices. Borat thinks that in England, you will be arrested if you try to court a woman; but that homosexuality is almost compulsory, certainly a necessary path to promotion in certain careers.

But if British man is having sexytimes with person who is not a girlie, he not arrested. On contrary, he given contract Channel 4 TV, seat in Parliaments and invitation go swimming with Michaels Barrymore.

He has noticed that English Christians are a persecuted minority:

Chrissiemas. Is banned because not inclusive other religions. Nowadays, British only allowed have religious ceremonies, prayers, days off, etc if not Christians.

Foreigners are given advantages over English people in employment:

If you Polish, just be plumber. Don't worry if can't tell hot tap from colds — British peoples think all Polish great plumbers. Otherwise, can pick fruit and vegetables, cleaning streets, become "ethnic" candidates on Conservatives' A-List.

(The nastiness of that final quip takes one's breath away.)

Borat has spotted the Most Important Issue Facing Britain Today:

In Britain, some women wear veils, mostly if radical teachers, lawyers etc hoping to get into papers, cause fuss, maybe pick up compensation monies.

And of course, he understand the British immigration system.

What to do when First Arrivings. Do not say: "I like very much Britain, long tradition freedom and democracy. Now I hoping work hard, raise family, and celebrate Christmas with all my friends, even the Jews." If say that, immigration officer reply: "Get lost, mateys, we don't want your kind here!" Do say: "I HIV-positive hijacker, sex criminal and terrorist fear persecution in own country. Now I hopings buy fake National Insurance number, claim benefits and plotting attacks on infidels, especially Jews."If you say that, immigration officer reply: "Certainly sir. Just jot your details down here. The Home Office should be able to lose them in a week or two.

Which is, being interpreted: "Me think England darn nice place. Much too nice for white man race."

Anyone who thinks that this is a parody of Daily Mail attitudes, intended to show how absurd they are, should run their eyes down the readers comments section. "Not too far from the truth...what a brilliant articles, its completely true...very funny but more importantly very true....this is the sort of country you get when you let the liberal elite be in charge and take orders from undemocratic institutions like the EC commission....profoundly and unfortunately true....frighteningly accurate description of Britain in terminal decline..."

You have to be quite careful with characters like Borat. Johnny Speight and Warren Mitchell had impeccable left wing credentials, but there were always a certain number of people who liked Alf Garnett because he said what they thought. Ali G is meant to be a complete pratt, but one got the impression that some people missed the joke and thought that he was quite cool. I have even heard stupid people repeating the phrase "Are you having a laugh?" over and over as if they thought that it was funny, where the entire point is that it isn't.

However, at their best, Ali G and Borat are powerful instruments of satire. A fictitious person expresses a ridiculous prejudice, and a real person reveals how stupid and bigoted they are by agreeing with them. In general, Ali G had to conduct long interviews with people in order to trap them: Sacha Cohen must be pretty chuffed that he is made the Daily Mail look stupid and bigoted without even going near their offices.

5 comments:

  1. This is truly astonishing.

    "But if British man is having sexytimes with person who is not a girlie, he not arrested. On contrary, he given contract Channel 4 TV, seat in Parliaments and invitation go swimming with Michaels Barrymore."

    The sheer lack of craftsmanship is almost painful to see. Does Borat sound anything like this at all? Has he ever use the phrase "on contrary"? And "he not arrested" sound more like Comical African than Borat.

    ReplyDelete
  2. ""But if British man is having sexytimes with person who is not a girlie, he not arrested. On contrary, he given contract Channel 4 TV, seat in Parliaments and invitation go swimming with Michaels Barrymore.""

    Translated into English, if a man is homosexual, is not arrested any more.

    Sheer, naked homophobia

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that the point of the "joke", and I use the term losely, is that heterosexuals are arrested for minor bad conduct (sexual harassment, using prostitutes, rape etc.) but homosexuals are given jobs in the media and government. I think the "not arrested" bit is Borat's prejudice, rather than the Mail's.

    The preceding paragraph runs:

    "In Britain, man is being arrested for

    • Having sex with girlies who too drunk say Yes or No.

    • Putting hands on bottoms, boobies girlies without her giving permissions.

    • Paying moneys to have sexytimes with girlies.

    But if British man is having sexytimes with person who is not a girlie...."

    ReplyDelete
  4. The piece combines terrible writing (it seems to be more written in the voice of Harry Enfield's Stavros than anything approaching Borat) with a vile, cheap meta-tone.

    But I am intrigued why you pick on the jab at the Tories' attempt at selecting specific candidates for winnable seats as particularly loathsome? Since it was based on discrimination in itself (albeit "positive") it seemed to me to be just about the only valid target in the entire piece.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I felt that the joke implied that any talentless person could become a Conservative candidate just because they had dark coloured skin; and that people with dark coloured skin became Conservative candidates as an easy way of making a fast buck, rathher than out of any belief in or committment to The Cause. (The idea that nearly everything that everyone does as a disreputable percuniary ulterior motive is a recurrent one in the Hate Mail.)

    ReplyDelete

Comments from SK are automatically deleted, unread, so please don't waste your time.