“But the Babel fish is a dead giveaway, isn’t it? It could not have evolved by chance. It proves you exist, and so therefore, by your own arguments, you don’t. QED”
Douglas Adams
Who Moved The Stone?
Frank Morrison
Evangelical Christians love conversion stories. Josh McDowell’s Evidence That Demands a Verdict concluded with a list of some fifty souls who started life outside the fold but eventually came to faith. Under the heading ‘Converted Skeptics’, we find Lew Wallace (who converted himself to Christianity while researching Ben Hur) CS Lewis (who knelt down in his college room and reluctantly let God be God)…and Frank Morrison, who set out to write a book debunking the resurrection and ended up convinced that it was literally true.
While I sincerely hope that very few people on this blog have read the Case for Easter, I assume many of you are familiar with Who Moved the Stone? If you have read it, you probably fall into one of two camps. Either you that think it more or less clears up all the difficulties and ambiguities in the four Gospels and stands as the final and clinching proof of the literal truth of the Christian faith. Or else you regard it as a comedic tissue of assumption, conjecture, circular reasoning and bet-hedging.
I wonder if Josh McDowell had read it?
It is quite true that Morrison frames the book, if not quite as a conversion narrative, then certainly as an account of how one person came to change their mind. (Someone has described it as “a brief from a hostile witness who flipped”.) The first chapter is famously called The Book That Refused To Be Written. But the unwritten book was never going to be entirely hostile to Christianity. Morrison says that he began with “a deep and even reverent” regard for Jesus as “an almost legendary figure of purity and noble manhood.” His idea seems to have been to write an account of the passion that rescued Jesus from the unnecessary, miraculous elements with which his story had been festooned.
So it is not all that surprising that the project didn’t work out. Practically everyone on all sides could have told him that if you remove the supernatural elements from the gospel story, what you are left with is close to zero.
Would Morrison’s approach have appealed to Josh McDowell or to any of the other evangelicals who wave the book around as a trophy text? He does not argue that the gospels are literally true: only that the surviving texts point to a coherent sequence of events. They are certainly not scripture, or the infallible word of God: they are ancient fragments from which it is possible to extract historical information. He is not an historian or a textual critic, although he knows more than he sometimes pretends to. He is not unaware that the synoptic gospels are interdependent, or that most scholars treat John’s gospel as a fictionalised apologetic. At one point, he mentions in passing that “everyone knows” what the apocryphal gospels of Peter and Nicodemus say about the guards outside Jesus’ tomb. But he largely takes it for granted that “Mark” is the John Mark mentioned in the book of Acts, and that Luke is the “beloved physician” from the epistle to the Colossians. And like Strobel’s experts, he is perhaps over-inclined to treat the texts as “testimonies” or “witness statements”. When the accounts disagree, his solution is generally not to harmonise them, but to deduce or hypothesise or (if you want to be unkind) invent an earlier version of the story which “must” lie behind the surviving texts.
The book is literally seeking an answer to the question “who moved the stone?” And it proposes a novel answer. Matthew says that when Mary Magdalene and her friends arrived at the tomb, they encountered an angel. Luke says that they encountered two angels. But Mark, the oldest source, says simply that they met “a young man...clothed in a long white garment.” And while Matthew says that the angel moved the stone by means of an earthquake, Mark and Luke both think it had already been rolled away by the time the women arrived.
Morrison wants us to take Mark at his word and say that the Sunday morning witnesses encountered a perfectly ordinary human visitor, who happened to have arrived a bit earlier than they did. He thinks Mark may have written his gospel precisely in order to correct the more far-fetched traditions that Matthew and Luke were propagating. And he even thinks he has worked out the young man’s identity: none other than the fugitive who ran away naked from Gethsemane.
The argument is quite clever. The young man is clearly not one of the twelve, but he apparently followed or accompanied them as they walked from the room of the last supper to Gethsemane. So he might very well have overheard what Jesus said to Peter a few minutes before his arrest: “But after that I am risen, I will go before you into Galilee.” He has no special insight: he is simply reminding the three women to remind the eleven disciples of what Jesus said.
Morrison is inclined to believe Matthew’s story, that there was a (presumably Jewish) guard outside Jesus’ tomb. He thinks that they must have somehow sensed that something was amiss; opened the tomb for themselves; and found that the body they were meant to be guarding was already gone. In a final flourish, he wonders if the young man could have been one of those guards. This would explain a cryptic remark in the apocryphal gospel of the Hebrews that the first witness to the resurrection, before James or Peter or Mary was “the servant of the priest”.
I hope that I will not be thought disrespectful or irreverent if I say that all this feels like a sustained exercise in Sherlockian fan fiction. Faced with a crux or contradiction in a text, Morrison invents or infers off-stage incidents which would explain what is going on: and then tends to assume that these inferred scenes must be what “really happened”.
But he is good at it: really, really good. I am almost inclined to say, a little too good. He can always take a neglected verse in one gospel and put it alongside a troubling verse in another and weave them into something which seems like a coherent whole. And he describes what Joseph and Pilate and Judas must have been thinking and feeling with a novelist’s eye.
But the more often he does it, the more one thinks that he could have done the same trick with any text. If the evidence were different, he could still have convinced the jury to deliver the verdict he wanted.
Here are a few examples of his approach.
1: The Arrest of Jesus
We are told that Judas Iscariot leaves the last supper early to betray Jesus to the priests. We are also told that Jesus and the disciples finish their meal and go to the garden where Jesus prays at length. The disciples fall asleep and are woken up several times. Then a party of Romans and Judeans come to arrest Jesus. So at least a few hours must have passed since Judas left. Why the delay?
Aha, says Morrison—but have you noticed that Pilate agrees to talk to the Jewish authorities first thing the next morning, without any fuss? And he asks Jesus if he really is the King of the Jews before anyone has told him that that is the charge against him. So obviously, when Judas arrived at the temple, the High Priest went to the palace and talked to Pilate in advance: there wouldn’t have been much point in arresting and condemning Jesus if Pilate wasn’t going to ratify their sentence.
And what was Pilate doing for the rest of the evening? Well, chatting to his wife, obviously: and you know what women are, inquisitive about everything! So she went to bed knowing that her husband was going to sentence a possibly innocent man to death the next morning. Is it any wonder she had bad dreams? And if she told them to her husband, is it any surprise that Pilate, who in secular sources is an undiplomatic thug, seems so reluctant to pass the sentence he’s already agreed to pass? But once the matter is settled, he goes ahead and puts the supremely tactless charge sheet “King of the Jews” on the cross. Which is very much what the fellow who brought graven images into Herod’s palace might be expected to have done.
It’s all very clever. If it turned up in an historical novel I would accept it without question.
What, incidentally, was the role of Judas? Jesus wasn’t in hiding, so the authorities didn’t need someone to reveal the location of his secret base. He was well known, so they didn’t need someone to point him out to them. Morrison’s solution is that the priests were genuinely scared of Jesus: they believed that he was a genuine miracle worker who might really destroy the temple. What Judas told them was that Jesus was in a passive and resigned state of mind, expecting to be arrested, so that if they came now, he wouldn’t resist.
Perhaps. Other fan-fics are available: Bart Ehrman thinks that Jesus had been secretly telling his disciples he was the true King of the Jews, but not proclaiming it to the crowd. So what Judas did was provide testimony that Jesus had committed high treason against the emperor.
Long-term readers may remember that I personally am inclined to see Judas as a mostly symbolic and anti-Semitic construct: a Jew called “Jew” who hands the Messiah over to the gentiles for hard cash.
2: The Missing Woman
In Mark’s Gospel, there are specifically three female witnesses to the crucifixion: Mary Magdalene, Mary the Mother of James and Joses, and someone called Salome. And also according to Mark, it is these three women who discover the empty tomb. But Mark also says, directly, that only two women witnessed Jesus’ interment: Mary Magdalene and Mary the Mother of Joses.
Why does he omit Salome?
Aha. Matthew also names the three women: but in his account they were Mary Magdalene, Mary the Mother of James and Joses and “the mother of Zebedee’s sons”. So it is perfectly reasonable to infer that Mark’s “Salome” and Matthew’s “mother of Zebedee’s sons” are one and the same—which makes her the mother of the disciples James and John, who are quite definitely the sons of Zebedee.
But according to John’s gospel, there was also a male witness to the crucifixion, namely “the disciple whom Jesus loved”. Pretty much everyone has always assumed that this “beloved disciple” is John—which is to say the brother of James, which is to say the son of Salome.
Now, in John’s Gospel, Jesus tells John (the beloved disciple) to take care of his mother after he is gone. So what must have happened is that when John left the execution site with Jesus’s distraught mother, his own mother, Salome went with them. She was a mum herself and would have wanted to do all she could to comfort Mary. They probably stayed at the house of yet another Mary, the sister of Martha and Lazarus, at Bethany, which would explain why those three are not mentioned in the Passion narratives.
There is nothing far-fetched or unreasonable about any of this. Morrison is not claiming that Mark intends us to make these inferences—indeed he probably doesn’t know the story about John taking Mary into his home. But Mark’s text happens to dovetail perfectly with Matthew’s and John’s: if you put them together they all form one clear narrative, which is pretty good evidence for them all going back to an historical source
But Morrison doesn’t always draw our attention to every link in his chain of reasoning. Was Salome really the same person as the mother of Zebedee’s sons? Was the beloved disciple really John? Was John the beloved disciple really John the brother of James? I agree with Morrison that the answer to all three questions is “probably”. But three or four cumulative “probablies” start to look progressively less certain.
In some cases, the chain gets stretched very thin indeed.
It should be remembered that Mary the wife of Clopas, and Salome were cousins….and both women were related to Mary the mother of Jesus.
Well….John says that the four women at the cross were Jesus’ mother, his mother’s sister, Mary the wife of Clopas, and Mary Magdalene. It is entirely unclear whether “his mother’s sister” and “Mary the wife of Clopas” are two different people, or if John is saying that Mary had a sister who married someone called Clopas.
If you take the second view, you are free to wonder if “Mary the Mother of James and Joses” and “Mary the wife of Clopas” are the same person. It would be very helpful if they were, because we are told elsewhere that James and Joses were the names of Jesus’s brothers. If Mrs Clopas is the sister of the Virgin Mary, the Pope is permitted to believe that James and Joses were actually Jesus’ cousins and the marriage of Mary to Joseph the carpenter was never consummated.
I don’t see how, by any stretch, Mary the wife of Clopas becomes Salome’s cousin. Morrison must here be relying on apocryphal sources.
3: Don’t mention the tomb.
Central to Morrison’s case is a rather substantial argument from silence.
Suppose, he says, that a big national monument like St Paul’s Cathedral burned to the ground. And suppose the first person to spot the fire was a policeman who passed the building in the middle of the night and observed smoke. No-one, writing about the fire or holding a public enquiry a few weeks later, would say “To confirm that the building really burned down, let’s call PC Dixon”. You wouldn’t need to confirm it: everyone can see that there is a smoking ruin over the river from Tate Modern. But years later, when telling the story, you might very well mention this interesting detail.
Now, however enthusiastically Paul may talk about the resurrection of Jesus, and however central it is to his faith, he never refers directly to the empty tomb. Neither do any of the disciples’ sermons quoted in the book of Acts.
Morrison sees two reasons for this. First of all, the Judeans were circulating a story that the disciples had moved Jesus body in order to fake the resurrection: so the very last thing any Christian wanted to do was to admit that half a dozen of them had indeed been pottering around the graveyard at the time of the crime. But in any case there would have been no point in telling the story: everyone in Jerusalem knew that Jesus’s body had really gone missing: anyone who doubted that could easily go and check. The primitive Christians didn’t talk about the tomb because everyone on all sides took it as a datum.
But note the corollary. If it could be shown that the primitive Christian witness did in fact use the empty tomb apologetically, then Morrison would have to withdraw that part of his case. “Since no-one talks about the tomb, it probably was really empty” only works if you are prepared to say “Since Christians talked incessantly about the empty tomb, the chances are they made the story up.”
In The Case For Easter Lane points out that while Paul doesn’t talk about the female witnesses, he is very definite that Jesus died and was buried and that he rose again on the third day. That very strongly implies an empty tomb, even though it doesn’t refer to it in so many words. And when Peter preaches to the Judeans on the day of pentecost he starts with a passage from Psalm 16 in which King David says to God “you will not abandon me to the realm of the dead / you will not let your holy one see decay”. Peter says that since King David did die “and his tomb is here to this day” he can’t have been referring to himself: he must have been talking about the messiah. Granted, Peter doesn’t go on to say “And if you don’t believe me ask one of the various Mary’s who checked out the tomb, as, in fact, did I myself”: but he is very definitely presupposing that something out of the ordinary happened to Jesus’ remains.
If this is correct, does it weaken Morrison’s argument? Or are apologists allowed to play “heads I win, tales you lose”? If the early Jesus movement didn’t proclaim an empty tomb, that is good circumstantial evidence that the tomb was really empty. But if they did proclaim it, then that is equally good evidence for the emptiness of the tomb.
Morrison does not draw any massive spiritual conclusions from his research. The book doesn’t finish with the Four Spiritual Laws or an exhortation to turn your life around. (He’s British, after all!) But he does capitalise Jesus’s pronouns throughout the text, and at one point refers to him as the Lord of Life. I believe he subsequently wrote religious columns in a British newspaper. His exercise in textual detective work and fan-fiction is meant to lead somewhere.
But where? Granted that we find his tendentious interpretation of the stone and the messenger convincing, what has been proved?
If I had to summarise his case, I would say:
“The four gospels and some secondary texts, cohere together remarkably well. A plausible narrative can be inferred from them, and it is hard to construct a more convincing counter-narrative which omits the supernatural. It is therefore reasonable to believe that the core claim is true: Jesus really did disappear from his grave, and his closest followers really did see him alive after he died.”
But what follows from this?
At one time, I would have regarded Who Moved the Stone? as decisive. I could have recited the central arguments by heart. There may even be embarrassing recordings of me on campus radio shows telling people that since there was no possible historical explanation of the quite definitely empty tomb, anyone who did not instantly become an evangelical Christian was guilty of intellectual dishonesty.
But even if Morrison is right—and I do think he does a pretty thorough job of demonstrating that the extant narratives have coherence and integrity—the apologetic exercise runs aground on one very large stone.
The objective fact of the resurrection wasn’t sufficient to convince Jesus’s actual disciples.
If you don't want to wait for the next installment, the complete 10-part series is already available to read on my Patreon.
Joining Patreon is the best possible way of telling me that you are enjoying my writing, and helping to keep producing these kinds of essays.
- Patreon Membership ($5/£3.75 month): Immediate access to all 10 parts and the rest of my Patreon archive (including exclusive essays on Spider-Man, CS Lewis, and the Rings of Power)
- Premium Membership ($10/£7.45 month): Includes free access to the complete series as a downloadable PDF book.
- One-Off Payment ($20/£15): Buy access to this specific Patreon collection.

No comments:
Post a Comment